Memorisation, writing and practice worked together from the generation of the Companions. Organised collection expanded, alongside scholarship about narrators and hidden defects.
The first generation
Memory, transmission and written records
Companions preserved the Prophet’s words and actions by accompanying him and practising his teaching. Hadith, letters and records were also written with his permission, including the records of Abdullah ibn Amr.
Abu Hurayrah described Abdullah ibn Amr writing hadith: Sahih al-Bukhari, Muhammad ibn Ismail al-Bukhari, hadith 113; a sound Companion statement, not a prophetic saying. Abu Said al-Khudri transmitted the prohibition: Sahih Muslim, Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj, hadith 3004; sahih. In his commentary on Muslim, al-Nawawi discusses different reconciliations of prohibition and permission, including risk of mixing material with the Quran and abrogation; one explanation is not presented as undisputed.
﴿ نٓ ۚ وَٱلْقَلَمِ وَمَا يَسْطُرُونَ﴾
Compilation
Organised collection with continuing criticism
Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz ordered wider collection around the turn of the first and second Islamic centuries. Muwatta collections, musannafs, musnads, Sahih collections and Sunan followed.
Collection was never automatic acceptance. Scholars examined narrators, dates, routes and wordings. Each book has its own aims and criteria.
Read carefully
Boundaries of understanding and application
Not exclusively oralWritten records existed during the Prophet’s lifetime.
Not a second Quranic codexThe entire Sunnah was not gathered in one official volume during his lifetime.
Inclusion is not a gradeSome collections contain both accepted and weak reports.
Lesson summary
What to remember
- 1Memorisation and writing began early.
- 2Compilation expanded gradually.
- 3Each collection has a method.
- 4Criticism accompanied collection.
Quick questions
Was hadith written during the Prophet’s lifetime?+
Yes, in records, letters and writings made with his permission.
Is every narration in a musnad authentic?+
No. Check the compiler’s method and the judgments of hadith specialists.
